Why are puppy mills still legal?

Maddy: Why are puppy mills legal?
Why are puppy mills legal? I guess I don't fully know what they do to the dogs there and I'm just curious.

I'm asking this because yesterday I went to the pet store int he small to play with the puppies in the back room and I chose a dachshund to play with. She was so small and sweet and I felt so bad for her. I know most dogs in pet stores come from puppy mills and when adopting them you support puppy mills but how does it support puppy mills? If they're already in the pet store haven't the puppy mills already been supported?

Please explain?

Answers and Views:

Answer by Feisty
In many states, they are NOT legal. They are raided all the time. However, until all states make a law and can afford to enforce the laws and pet stores no longer use them, puppy mills will be around.

Answer by Naysaツ **R.I.P Michael Jackson**
Like all places who sell goods... They buy whats in demand, then we come along and buy what popular, there for making the stores need to buy more to supply us with what we want. Thats the simple way of putting it.. Its supply and demand. Also if people boycotted pet shops, and didn't buy the pups, then the pet store would stop buying from the puppy mill, there for no longer supporting them

I have no freaking clue why they're legal.

Answer by Marigold
If you buy a puppy from a pet store then the pet store can buy another puppy from the puppy mill or puppy mill broker. It is a cycle that will not stop unless people stop buying.
For example: John buys a puppy from a pet store. The pet store has to get another puppy to sell so they buy another puppy from the broker or directly from the puppy mill. So that the next John can buy a puppy.
If John 1 wouldn't have bought from there then a new puppy wouldn't have been brought in from the puppy mills.

They are not legal.

Answer by gentlegiants
You are right on the mark. Buying the dog does help keep the puppy mills going, but you'd be rescuing the puppy so it's a real dilemma.
It's a no win situation. If you loved the dog, buy it and do the right thing for the dog, by spaying or neutering and giving it lots of love and attention.

Answer by dobiz_rule
how buying from a pet store supports puppy mills. the answer is the law of supply and demand.
in this case demand drives supply. (Demand is how many people are willing to buy from the pet store and Supply is how many dogs the puppy mill can provide to meet the demand)
so the more people are buying from pet stores the more demand it creates which causes puppy mills to produce more dogs. if there was NO demand, pet stores would not want to buy puppies from puppy mills (because no one would buy them in the store) and in turn puppy mills would stop producing dogs because no one was buying them!

as for why they are legal. because dogs are treated the same as cattle by law. nothing more than a piece of property. law doesn't consider them living creature and they really have no "rights" in the eyes of the law

Answer by paint1boxers
Because puppy mills come in different forms- from I want my girl dog to have puppies because she is sooo cute! to the ones that have hundreds of dogs in crates with no exercise and raise one litter after another without ever knowing the joy of running in the grass or being loved. Breeders raise dogs to show and prove they have met or improved the breed standard, they spend thousands of dollars every year for health testing,& going to shows, they not only keep their old dogs, but they rescue dogs too. Their is no money made for reputable breeders. Millers don't spend any money on health, breed anything with reproductive organs, and kill dogs no longer able to reproduce. The Department of Agriculture can't shut down the millers without making laws putting breeders out of business. Sometimes they are raided, and the dogs seized, but it would put all millers out of business if people would just stop buying their dogs. Buy from a Breeder who cares about their dogs, and love them. Check out Best Friends Animal Sanctuary on the Web also known as Dog Town for more information.

Answer by Rayven~Summer Troll Patrol
Commercial breeding is legal. The horrid conditions of 95% of mills is whats legal. Animals are property and can be massed produced.

When you buy from a pet shop you open up space for them order more pups from the mills or broker they deal with. Simple supply and demand.

Read other answers in the comments.

Add your own answer!




  1. show breeders sell sick pups. says

    as long as they follow rules they are allowed to run...but any violations they can be shut down....our animal control has to check each kennel once a month to make sure there's no violations..i would support a puppymill before a reputable breeder...

  2. Anna <3 says

    in most states puppy mills actually are not illegal. puppy mills are known for treating their dogs poorly and not giving them the proper treatment or care. police raids happen all the time due to health code violations ect. ect.
    most pet stores buy puppy from pupy mills because they can get the dog extreamly cheap. if you dont buy from the pet store they wont need pupp mills because they wont need any dogs. so basicly no sales no need for the mills....i dont know if i excplained that well...if you have any quesions let me know.

  3. BYBS abuse their pets says

    because its not illegal to house several hundred dogs if you have the proper space and licences

    Its not illegal to breed dogs

    Its not illegal to breed dogs every heat cycle

    its not illegal to breed unhealthy dogs.

    The only time puppy mills get shut down is when you can proove that they are neglecting or abusing their animals.. many of them are inspected and do meet minimal standards on sanitization and care.. its not considered cruel to house several dogs together in a small cage and breed the crap out of them.. so long as they do have adequate shelter, food, water, and are recieving medical treatment for obvious illness/injuries.. ("adequate" is a loose term) not all puppy mills are inspected routinly tho, but they pretty much NEVER let anyone inside the facility.

    If you buy that puppy.. you send a message to the petshop that there is still a market for puppies.. an empty cage means they have to order MORE puppies from the puppy mill.

    If no one buys the puppy.. the petshop owner will realize there is not a market for puppies, and will not continue to buy from the puppy miller.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *